Wherever groups of men work in adverse conditions, a unique sense of humour is born. It may be altered and augmented by the influence of social and political affairs but basically it remains a product of the men and their working conditions. The building site, the shipyard, the steelworks and the barracks all have their characteristic humour and the mine is no exception.
Mining humour is born in a hostile environment, nurtured in arduous working conditions and matured by the telling and retelling in the convivial atmosphere of pub, club and "smoker". At times it may be savagely critical but rarely vindictive.
Pit Patter contains but a small cross section of pit humour, it being difficult to encompass the full range and depth of such a subject in a short publication. Indeed, many situations are only humorous at the time of their making and in the context of known personalities and places, so that this rich seam of spontaneous humour cannot be captured in cold print, but is better left to verbal recall with those immediately involved.
In an attempt to reach a wider audience, some stories are prefaced by an explanation which may help the reader to appreciate the humour. Similarly, the colourful adjectives so common in speech below ground have been somewhat tempered in the interests of propriety. Genuine names and places have only been used when necessary for the spirit of the story and, in such cases, no offence is intended.
Many times during my 40 years of direct
association with the mining industry, first as a miner and latterly
as a mining lecturer, I have heard it said that, "these
stories should be written down", but, like many other good
intentions, little has been done and a generation of mining humour
may be about to pass unrecorded. I hope that Pit Patter will
stimulate others in recalling their own favourite stories and give
to them the same pleasure it has given me.
WORKINGS AND THE WORKERS
The depth of mine workings in Fife varied from a
few feet in the early days to thousands of feet in the new larger
mines. There are many stories regarding the depth of shafts and
associated workings in older mines.
One, from The History of The Fife Coal Company,
by Augustus Muir, refers to the journeys around the pits made on
horseback by the Manager, Charles Carlow. It tells how the miners
at the old Blairenbathie Pit knew when the manager was coming by
the call of the peewits; the pit was so shallow that those working
at the shaft bottom could hear the warning cries of the birds
disturbed by the thud of the horse's hooves as the young
manager rode up!
Some other stories are not so
idyllic.
A young Bevin Boy, about to descend the pit shaft at the training centre for the first time, timidly asked the banksman if the shaft was deep and got the reply; "Naw naw laddie, it's no' that deep, at piece time the pit bottomer reaches his haund up the shaft and pings the pithead lassies' gerters!"
Then there was the story attributed to the Jenny Gray Pit which claimed that the workings were so near to the surface that, at piece time, the workmen emerged through a hole in the field to play football.
Or the Dora Pit where, if the strippers set their supports too tight to the roof, they jammed up the doorsteps of the miners' rows and the women couldn't get out the back door to hang their washing.
Or Fordell Pit where a deputy walked in the gate road rubbing his head, complaining bitterly; "The fermer's plooin' his field again and he's had ma bannet aff three times comin' in the road."
When the mines were nationalised in 1947 the
Fife Coal Company's policy of centralised services such as
workshops, planning, mechanical and electrical engineering, safety
and legal etc., serving a large number of collieries in scattered
locations, was taken as a model for the new National Coal Board
(NCB). However, not even the Fife Coal Company could have envisaged
the rapid expansion and duplication of the services provided at
Division, Area, Group and Colliery level and the proliferation of
additional services such as training, materials, large coal,
mechanisation, strata control and many more.
Miners cynically referred to the
disproportionate number of "chiefs" compared
to "indians" and that the expense
"a' had tae come frae the point o' the pick".
The
following story was current in those times as a measure of the
indians' concern for the great increase in the number of
"chiefs".
At the local cemetery an old miner was being
laid to rest amid a large gathering of family and friends. The old
miner's son was perturbed to see an unknown, well dressed man,
in obvious distress and weeping copiously into a large white
handkerchief. The son, who had been responsible for issuing the
invitations to the funeral, was apprehensive in case he had omitted
a member of the family or a best friend from the invitation list
and approached the still grieving man at the end of the service.
"Are ye family?" he asked.
"No," was the
reply.
"Are ye a close freend?"
"No."
"Dae ye ken the auld man?"
"No."
By this time the son was becoming exasperated and
curtly asked.
"Well what are ye daen here?"
The man
burst
into another fit of tears and choked out.
"I'm attending
this funeral in my official capacity as the newly appointed NCB
Area Bereavement Officer and will you please sign my attendance
sheet?"
The planning department also came in for
some"stick".
Under the ambitious "Plan for Coal", a
large amount of money was available for spending on capital
projects to increase output and productivity. Schemes to provide
new sinkings, modernise existing pit layouts and to provide new
machinery abounded. Older miners, who had experienced the financial
strictures of the private coal companies and had been subjected to
the difficulties associated with wartime shortages, were both
amazed and cynical at the apparently lavish outpouring of money.
Doom and disaster were predicted and, as inevitably, some of these
grandiose schemes foundered, they felt justified in their
predictions.
For example, I recall the prophecies of the old
Kinglassie miners who had worked the coals on the East Side
district and which ultimately had to be abandoned due to faulting
and thinning of the seams. They maintained that the new sinking at
Rothes, to work an extension of the coals from the East Side
District, would be a "white elephant".
Although there were many contributing factors
leading to the early demise of Rothes, the Kinglassie miners felt
justified when one of the factors proved to be excessive faulting
and thinning of the seams.
It was in this context that the story was told
of the two retiring deputies from Kinglassie, who had just attended
a meeting in the Personnel Department at Cowdenbeath Central
Offices. They were leaving the premises at exactly 5.00pm, when a
bell rang. Immediately, a large number of people disgorged
themselves from a wing of the main building.
"What's that?" said a deputy,
pointing towards the building. "
That's the Planning
Engineer's Office," replied the other, indicating the wing
of the main building.
"Ah kent it," muttered the first
deputy.
"Ye kent what?" enquired the second.
"Ah
kent that wan man couldnae mak a' they cock-ups oan 'is
ain!"
(I first heard this story from Bert Finlay,
Explosive Store Attendant at Kinglassie Colliery, who compiled the
column "The First Tow" in the newspaper, the "Weekly
News". Such was Bert's expertise at topical news gathering
that it was said that Kinglassie Managers got as much information
about their pit from his column as they did from the statutory
reports!)
The run-down of the pits during the war due to
the shortage of manpower and materials, and the increased demand
for coal in the 1950s, all combined to make it a "coal at
any price" time.
Miners were exhorted to reduce absenteeism, work
extra shifts, were "given" a bonus shift for perfect
attendance, and coal was rationed. One of the perks allocated to
the miners was food parcels made up from Army surplus tinned
rations. Each allocation consisted of about ten battleship-grey
coloured tins, but without labels or other identifying marks. At
home, the tins were lined up on the kitchen table and attempts made
to deduce the contents. One method was to shake the tin vigorously,
which at least distinguished between solid and liquid, but there
the contest ended. A solid tin, anticipated to be filled with prime
juicy steak, could turn out to be a lump of stodgy "spotted
dick" pudding, and a liquid tin, confidently predicted to be
filled with mouth-watering peach slices, could buck the system and
take the form of dark, obnoxious prune juice.
Against this background of "perks to the
miners" the following story circulated.
Apparently, in the
discussions leading up to the Festival of Britain, fear was
expressed that the substantial number of London prostitutes who
were enthusiastically self-employed, and advertised their wares at
street corners, would sully the Capital's reputation and should
be driven from soliciting in the streets. Protesters pointed out
that this would deliver the trade into the shady underworld of
illegal brothels controlled by the pimps and vice barons of
organised crime. Debate raged fiercely and even entered the House
of Lords.
A headline appeared in a National newspaper.
LORDS SAY THAT LONDON PROSTITUTES WILL BE DRIVEN UNDERGROUND
An English MP, whose appreciation of Britain and miners stopped short at the Watford Gap, was heard to mutter. "Trust these bloody miners, they get everything that's going!"
On the subject of absenteeism there was the
story of the workman who was brought before the Pit Absentee
Committee for persistent absenteeism and was asked.
Why do you only work four shifts a
week?" "Because Ah cannae live on three," was the
answer.
There was a big influx of Irish workers at this
time and of course "Irish" jokes flourished.
The tale was told of two Irish peat cutters who
thought they would "con" a mine manager into giving them
a job below ground, although they had never worked in a mine
before. The first went in for interview and thought he had
successfully dealt with all the questions the manager had thrown at
him concerning his work experience below ground, until he was asked
what type of lamps he had used. At a loss, the Irishman answered,
"Paraffin lamps Sur."
This confirmed his inexperience and
the Manager sent him packing.
Passing the second Irishman waiting to go into
interview, the first whispered, "It's OK, but remember, we
don't use paraffin lamps."
The second interview followed
the same pattern as the first until the Manager said, "I
suppose you used paraffin lamps as well?"
"No Sur, Ah
didnae need a lamp because Ah was on constant dayshift," was
the reply.
On the subject of interviews, the Manager was
interviewing two Nigerians for work underground. One Nigerian was
built like the proverbial "brick cludgie" while the other
would not have looked out of place among the pygmies. The Manager
said to the big black man, "I think I can find a place for you
but I'm afraid I've nothing for your wee pal."
The big
man looked down disdainfully at the little one and exclaimed,
"Him no ma pal, him ma piece!"
The "piece" was an emotive subject at
the pit and many an argument took place over the relative merits of
various fillings. Slice or link sausage, scrambled egg, roast beef,
all had their adherents although, during the shortages of wartime,
many a ton of coal was won from "two on jam and two on
spam".
Many miners preferred "Dundee steak" as a
filling. This was simply thick slices of cheese liberally spread
with home made marmalade or jam. I think it was popular with the
housewife because it was simple to prepare and relatively cheap (a
prime consideration in a household of many workers) but its
attraction for the miner lay in that combination of piquancy and
moistness so necessary to rejuvenate the tastebuds after prolonged
assaults from coal dust and shotfiring fumes.
A young miner was living in "digs" and
the landlady made up one slice of bread with "Dundee
steak" for his piece. When the landlady asked him if he had
enjoyed the piece he replied, "OK, but can ah no hae a wee bit
mair?"
The landlady put two slices in the piece box the
next day but got the same answer to her question. This went on
until six slices were made up but still without satisfaction to the
lodger.
The landlady made a last despairing effort to
please. She cut a loaf in half, spread both sides with best butter
and inserted thick slices of boiled ham garnished with lettuce and
mayonnaise. When the lodger was asked the fateful question at the
end of the shift he replied;
"It was great, but ah see
ye're back tae the wan slice!"
The Training Officer was interviewing applicants
for the Colliery first aid team and asked a young man why he wanted
to be a member.
"To help my workmates," said the
applicant. "I remember the big accident in the pit bottom when
men were lying around screaming in pain; blood was everywhere. I
couldn't do a thing for them and I felt right
incontinent."
"You mean incompetent," suggested the
Training Officer.
"Listen pal, I was there and I know how I
felt," came the correction.
The 1960s saw the "Roben's
Round" of pit closures. At first, surplus men were
accommodated in surviving local pits, but eventually these pits
could not viably accept any more men and it was either the
"Dole" or transfer to more productive pits in England,
mainly around Coventry and Mansfield.
Many miners had a stark choice. Stay in Scotland
as a mining "nomad", transferring from pit to pit as the
closure policy accelerated, or uproot the whole family to an
uncertain future south of the Border.
It must be remembered, however, that mining is
an extractive industry and pit closures due to exhaustion of
reserves is inevitable. In addition, in the era of the private coal
companies, men often changed pits to secure better pay and
conditions. This migration was further enhanced by the frequent
transfer of colliery managers, where it was customary for them to
transfer to the new pit with a nucleus of skilled, loyal workers
from their previous pit.
A story told at that time concerned
several young miners who were bemoaning
the fact that they had been transferred six
times in as many years. They were overheard by an old miner who had
changed pits a number of times in the scheme of working prevalent
in his time but had always managed to find suitable housing for his
family, a few hens and the inevitable "doos".
"Ye've seen nothing yet lads," he said,
"Ah've changed pits sae often that, every time a big
furniture van passes the hoose, the hens lay doon on their backs
tae get their legs tied up!"
The same miner told the story of when, in 1939,
he had transferred from the Lanarkshire Coalfield, with its shallow
compact pits, to the East Fife pits which had extensive workings
reaching out several miles under the Firth of Forth.
After a week
of unaccustomed long journeys to the working face involving
transport by rope haulage, locomotive haulage and finally a long
back-breaking walk through low roadways, he was resigned to the
fact that he spent more time "marching" than
"fighting".
At the Club, on Saturday night, a local miner
remarked, "Ah see that the Germans are thinkin' aboot
declarin' war on us."
"Ah'm no surprised,"
came the cynical reply, "ye've been stealing their coal
fur years!"
There was also the story about the three
machine-men who had agonised for weeks over whether to stay in
Scotland or seek their fortune over the Border.
At least, two of
them agonised while Wull, the cable-man was indifferent. His job
was to pull the heavy electrical trailing cable, connected between
the machine and permanent switchgear, along the faceline at such a
rate as to ensure that the progress of the cutting machine was not
impeded by the slack.
It required great strength and concentration
to deal with 150 yards of heavy cable, especially in steep seams,
and Wull's thoughts rarely strayed from the state of his
cable.
One night the agonising was over and, as they
descended in the cage, Wull's leading man said.
"We've
decided the nicht, we're gaun doon tae Coventry."
A slight
frown crossed Wull's face as he replied.
"OK, but dae ye
think we'll hae enough cable?"
Nicknames were common at pits. There was the
usual clutch of universal byenames such as "Nobby" Clark,
"Dusty" Miller and "Chalky" White; but at pits
where the bulk of the manpower was drawn from small, close-knit
mining communities, specific nicknames were bestowed as a means of
identification.
This was mainly as a result of large families with
common surnames and the age old custom (now rarely used) of naming
the first born son after the paternal grandfather or father. With
the large families of those days, auld Tammy Trout, the
grandfather, could have his name perpetuated many times by a brood
of dutiful sons, and in the fullness of time, many Trouts and
several
Tammy Trouts would appear in the local mines.
Nicknames were then used to discriminate between men who had the
same forename and surname.
Nicknames could be allocated by age,
"Auld" Tam and "Young" Tam; by main profession,
"Brusher" Trout and "Packy" Trout,
"Piper" Trout and "Drummer" Trout; by location,
"Hatchbank" Tam; by religious persuasion,
"Irish" Tam; by drinking prowess, "Boozy" Tam,
or "Half-pint" Tam. Indeed any characteristic which
separated namesakes was employed as a means of identification. The
origin of other nicknames such as "Jingler",
"Bugler", "Rook", "Skin" and
"Benghazi" was more obscure and there were many
conflicting stories as to how they had been first
applied.
Everyone who had emigrated from behind the Iron
Curtain, irrespective of country of origin, was classified as
Polish, with the result that there were quite a few named "Joe
the Pole" or "Waddy the Pole", even though they were
nominally Estonians, Ukranians, Czechs or Rumanians.
An example of "overkill" in the use of
nicknames for identification purposes was apparent at a pit which
employed the only coloured man in the area. He was known as
"Larry the Darkie" (shades of the Racial Discrimination
Act).
Probably the ultimate in positive identification was to be
witnessed at the local Ex-Servicemans Club where, pinned discreetly
at one end of the glass fronted main noticeboard, was a list of
members who had been suspended for committing sundry misdemeanours.
About halfway down the list of names came the entry;
J. WILSON
(NOT TUG).
It was probably Larry who circulated the story
that he was the son of an African Chief and had to report regularly
on his stay in the Fife coalfield. He reported on the social
customs of his colleagues who gathered after work in large clubs
where much drinking took place.
The favourite pastime was throwing small spears,
tipped with iron at one end and decorated with feathers at the
other, at a round board with numbers on it.
The winner of the game
was entitled to free beer from the other participants. Larry's
experience of spear throwing in the jungle stood him in good stead
and he was a frequent winner. The Chief was intrigued with this
account and saw the game as a means of improving the prowess of the
members of his spear throwing bodyguard, so he asked Larry to find
out the name of the game.
Larry replied that the game seemed to
have many names, but the most oft repeated were HOOZFURRAGEMME and
YALUKKYBLAKBUGGER.
Miners sometimes gave their wives nicknames,
some endearing and some not so, much depending on the occasion. One
miner christened his wife "The Tiger". Whether he
perceived the Tiger as a beautiful, regal creature or as a vicious,
snarling predator we could not fully ascertain, but I suspect that
his perception altered with his (her) moods. While sitting around
at piece time, we were usually acquainted with her latest exploits,
and it was then our task to separate fact from fiction. He had been
absent from work one day and was asked for the reason the following
day.
"The Tiger slept in," was the
reply.
"That's no' like her,"
commented his workmates.
"Ah ken, the alarm went aff and Ah
waukened but the Tiger lay still. Ah sat up until Ah kent that Ah
had missed the last bus but the lazy besom never steered and let me
sleep in. By God, Ah geen her a piece o' mah mind when she did
wauken!"
On another occasion, after a night of glorious
imbibing, he was dreamily and unsuccessfully trying to put his
boots on at 4.00 am in the morning, not relishing another hard
shift at the pit.
"Wauken up ya dozy sicht, ye're
pittin' yer bits oan the wrang feet," remonstrated the
Tiger.
"Richt again darlin'," came the sweet
response, "they should be oan your bloody
feet!"
An Arab dignitary was visiting Britain and
requested to view the workings of a coal mine. His request caused
some difficulty with accommodation as the entourage contained his
harem and many slave servants. These difficulties were overcome and
the Sheik was conducted down a coal mine where he saw men wrestling
heavy hutches of coal on to the cage, transporting girders and
heavy machinery to the face, stripping coal while shrouded in a
cloud of agonised sweat and many other difficult and dangerous jobs
associated with coal mining. After the visit, he was standing in
the Manager's Office, musing over what he had seen, when the
"lousing horn" sounded. In a trice the pithead was alive
with men as they disembarked from the cages, scurried noisily down
the pithead stairs over to the baths and finally, were whisked away
by lines of waiting 'buses. The Arab seemed spellbound by this
activity and when the Manager asked if he had any questions about
the visit, he replied.
"Only one, how the hell do you catch them
again?"
Workmen rarely carried measuring instruments,
reliance being placed on less accurate but readily available means.
For instance, in an emergency, the standard rail gauge of 23 inches
readily converted into "an elby, a haund and twa
fingers". This sufficed, provided the measurer was not of an
abnormal stature. The distance between the conveyor and new line of
supports was given by a "pick shaft" or multiples
thereof, depending on the depth of coal cut.
Similarly, capacity could be quantified in terms
of "a tithfy" (a minute amount), "a moothfy" (a
moderate amount), and the ultimate, "a hutchfy".
It was
no surprise, therefore, when a miner received a postcard from a
colleague on holiday which read, "Having a great time, only
three pan length tae the nearest bathroom, 25 chocks tae the beach
and there's talent by the hutchfy".
SUPERVISION
In modern times, the onerous task of deploying
the manpower on a main production shift is aided by new technology.
Computer databases store details of the aptitudes and statutory
qualifications of workmen and officials. This database is matched
to a colliery working plan and, as personnel pass certain locations
such as the time office, lamp room and pit head, they are
electronically scanned like items at a supermarket checkout. This
information is checked against the colliery working plan, which
itself is constantly updated from information about the state of
readiness of the working faces, additional work required for safety
and the effects of absenteeism.
By the time the workman reaches the deployment
point below ground he has been electronically compared, selected
and allocated in accordance with the working plan. Before this
technological revolution, the deployment of manpower was
usually
the function of the senior overman (Gaffer) for
the shift and, on the main production shift at a large colliery,
could entail the judicious placement of over three hundred
men.
It was a scene that never ceased to amaze me.
There stood this imperious figure in a conspicuous position as the
workmen passed by on their way into the districts. Rather like a
Caesar reviewing his legions as they marched to battle. He was
flanked by the centurions (district overmen) feeding him
information on the state of their districts while the scribes
(deputies) faithfully recorded any changes to be made to the battle
plan. Hovering in the background were the reserves, the ranks of
spare men who had no regular task or whose normal task was not
available due to geological or other adverse conditions.
Armed with information from a myriad of sources
such as the "early lousers" he had met on his way to the
pit, verbal reports from officials on the previous shift, statutory
written reports, manager's briefing, the time office and
pithead, the Gaffer issued his instructions to the passing stream
of men. Cancelling work here, augmenting a depleted team from the
pool of spare men, allocating men from the pool to additional work
of vital importance, until all the men at the muster point had been
successfully deployed.
As teams passing the deployment point reported
manpower deficiencies there were two alternatives; either the team
could work short-handed or they could be allocated men from the
spare pool. This situation required delicate handling as a team
which regularly worked short-handed could find that, when a new
contract was negotiated, the occasional reduction was now regarded
as the "norm". Conversely, sharing the price of a task
among less men could be attractive, especially in the weeks leading
up to the holidays.
No doubt the overall task of manpower
deployment could be performed more
easily and quickly by computer but the Gaffer
brought a humanity to the occasion which no computer could match.
Could the spare men he was deploying work well with others in the
team? Was team A more suitable for a task than team B? Take into
account that the spare man had just returned after injury and
needed a few more "light" shifts before taking up his
former employment, or that another spare man required some highly
paid shifts as there had been an addition to an already large
family. And so on.
When conditions were good the Gaffer completed
the deployment with scarcely a word or backward glance, men and
management being broadly satisfied that the best interests of the
pit had been served.
However, on one occasion, there were serious
complications caused by poor geological conditions in one district,
a suspected heating in another and an unusually high absenteeism
rate even for a Monday morning. Further complications arose from
the fact that the Gaffer was in a filthy mood, the cause of which
was never found out. Into this seething pot was stirred two Asian
gentlemen from University who were attending their first shift of
work experience between academic terms. But this was not an
occasion for the usual exchange of names and pleasantries. As the
Gaffer wrestled with conflicting priorities against a background of
depleted manpower, claims for more men were met with an irritated,
"Och, tak a darkie."
"The darkies" were soon
oversubscribed but no one had the courage to contradict the Gaffer,
and men who had been allocated mythical "darkies"
ruefully but diplomatically decided to work with a reduced team.
The pit grapevine rapidly relayed the message that, contrary to
popular opinion, the Gaffer was fallible, and he was constantly but
gently reminded of the episode when the phrase, "we'll tak
a darkie", became the standard response of a team willing to
work short-handed.
The deputy (or fireman in older times) is the "front line supervisor"; responsible for safety, recording attendance, noting abnormal working conditions and supervising the day to day operations in his section of the mine. He is the direct link between management and workmen and as such, often had the unenviable task of being fair to both sides. There are many stories of his efforts in this respect.
A workman had transferred to a new pit and,
until he was allocated to a regular task, was subject to the whims
of the district deputy. No sooner had he completed one task than
the deputy had given instructions for another. This continued to
the end of the shift when the workman asked the deputy. "By
the way, what did ye say the name o' this pit was?"
"Blairhall," said the deputy, "why are ye
askin'?"
"Och, the wey you've had me rinnin'
aboot a' shift ah thocht it was Pootherhall!"
Men were working up to the knees in water which
had broken into a section of the mine. The deputy paid "water
money" of 50p a shift to every workman except Tam who only got
25p. The dispute reached the manager who could not understand why,
as the deputy was known to be scrupulously fair. He called both men
to a meeting in his office.
"Why do you pay everybody 50p
water money while Tam only gets half?" he asked.
"Roll up yer left trooser leg Tam,"
said the deputy, and there, for everyone to see, was a well-crafted
aluminium artificial leg, extending up to the knee!
Water usually appears in a working area through
breaks in the roof and affects all men working on the face but, on
one occasion, water started bubbling up through the soft fireclay
floor on the "waste" side of the conveyor. Out of a total
face complement of around forty men, the only workmen affected were
four prop drawers who worked in the waste area. At first, the
discomfort to the prop drawers was slight and the deputy dismissed
the half-hearted demands from the prop drawers for water money.
However, conditions deteriorated and by the end of the shift the
prop drawers were coated with a water/fireclay mud which dried like
cement.
The prop drawers decided to appeal to the
section overman and the leading man stayed behind to confront him
on the following shift. Sitting on the waste side of the conveyor,
white with caked fireclay, the leading prop drawer used his hand to
brush aside the thick layer of coal spillage which covered the
floor, thus exposing the water bubbling up through the
fireclay.
"Look at that Jock," he appealed to
the overman who was sitting on the dry side of the conveyor. The
overman lifted his arms and made the gesture of inspecting the roof
for evidence of water, saying;
"Aw, fair's fair Jim, if ye dig doon
deep enough in the Sahara ye'll get watter!"
Jim's
answer can best be described as "expletives
deleted".
The Mines Inspector had commented unfavourably
about the siting of electrical switchgear (panels) at the side of a
roadway and insisted that the panels should be placed in a properly
constructed panel house. The Manager instructed the Deputy to
ensure that this was carried out as soon as possible and sought a
daily verbal progress report from him.
"Is it finished, is it
big enough?" were the constant queries of the
Manager.
"Its gaun fine," was the usual reply
from the Deputy.
The Manager was advised that the Inspector would
be visiting the Colliery the following day and made a point of
seeking out the Deputy.
"Is it finished noo?" he asked
apprehensively.
"Aye it's finished noo," was the
somewhat exasperated reply.
Noo ye're share it's big enough
tae haud a set o' panels?"
"A set o' bloody
panels? It's big enough tae haud a set o' bloody
quadrilles."
A deputy had only a passing physical resemblance
to Edward G Robinson but maybe it was this short stature, together
with the loud staccato way in which he gave his instructions, that
gave him his place with the workmen as "the little boy with
the man's voice".
A workman had collapsed while building a stone
pack on the face, some 50 yards from the top road. He was
physically incapable and rambling incoherently as his workmates
brought him, with difficulty, to the top road (it was found later
that his condition was allegedly due to the reaction between a raw
penicillin injection and a pound of ripe pears consumed before he
came on shift).
A workman was sent to the outbye end of the road to
'phone the Deputy, who was in a remote part of the district,
for instructions.
"Tam's no weel," he shouted over
the 'phone.
"What's wrang wi' him?" replied
the Deputy, weighing up the possibilites of having to travel a fair
distance to administer first aid, detail men from an already
depleted workforce to escort Tam to the surface, and his duty to
ensure that all the tasks in the district had to be completed
before the oncoming shift arrived.
"Tam's lost his memory
and disnae ken where he is," said the workman.
"Is that a'?" replied the Deputy.
"Gi'e him a strong cup o' tea, tell him he's in
the tap road o' the Bank Seam, then send him doon the face tae
finish aff his pack!"
The new undermanager was convinced that he could
get more work out of the daywage men and decided to carry out a
work study. The first man he questioned was the conveyor attendant
(button man) where coal transferred from the main gate conveyor to
the trunk conveyor.
"What dae ye dae at the beginnin'
o' the shift?" he asked.
"Och, ah inspect the cable,
see that the load's awricht and generally tidy up,"
replied the button man.
"And what dae ye dae when the
coal's comin'?"
"Och, ah see that it's
loadin' richt and shovel up the spillage."
"But whit
dae ye dae when the coal's no comin'?" leered the
undermanager.
A slight frown and then came the studied answer;
"Och, ah jist tell the wife tae pit in anither coal
line!"
Then there was the deputy who claimed that he
had been in charge of a longwall district in the Ashanti gold mines
and had to constantly shout up the faceline; "Break up yer big
gold, it's jammin' the pans in the roadheed!"
Or, on
occasions;
"Throw yer gold in the waste, we're
gaun tae hae a cut-through!"
THE RESCUE SERVICE
When the normal hazards of mining are compounded
by emergencies caused
by fire, flood and explosion, men of the Mines
Rescue Service are invariably involved. It was my privilege to be a
member of this service and to experience the enhanced esprit de
corps so prevalent among men who work in adverse and
life-threatening situations.
Rescue Stations, each serving a number
of pits, were established in the coalfield. The stations could be
designated full-time, where the men were permanently employed at
the station in work and practice, or part-time, where
each colliery appointed brigadesmen from the
colliery staff who would be summoned by the Rescue Station when an
emergency arose, and who would undertake practice in rescue work on
at least six occasions per year.
After Nationalisation in 1947 there was one
full-time and four part-time rescue stations in Scotland. There
were advantages and disadvantages in each set-up, but it could be
said that part-time brigadesmen did not have the same opportunities
to train and practice as did their full-time counterparts. In an
effort to improve this situation the NCB, in 1953, introduced the
Mines Rescue Competition which was open to teams (five men) of
part-time brigadesmen attached to collieries. Each station held a
competition and the two top teams from each station then went
forward to the Scottish Inter-Station Final.
The event started
slowly, as many rescue men were not sold on the principle of
competition in rescue work. However, momentum gathered, fostered
mainly by good organisation within the NCB, support from mining
unions and associations, and the natural rivalry between teams,
collieries and rescue stations. Venues for the inter-station
competition improved from an isolated wind-swept training centre at
Calderhead (near Shotts) to the relatively salubrious facilities of
Brunton Halls in Musselburgh.
Prizes were awarded for the best team in the
Oral Examination, the best team in the Gallery Examination, and the
Challenge Cup was awarded to the overall winner. Some time later,
prizes for individual performance in the Oral Examination were
awarded and these trophies were prized by the rescue men as highly
as the Gold Medal is valued by Olympic competitors.
At an Inter-Station Competition, held at one of
the superior venues, a retired rescue man had occasion to visit the
toilets and, on entering, was confronted by a cream tiled wall upon
which, at regular intervals and at a suitable height, were fixed
white bowls of distinctive shape. These tributes to the ceramic
sculptors' art bore their signatures in a pale blue script -
Shanks and McEwan.
The absence of hot and cold taps confirmed that
these were indeed separate urinals. The man could be forgiven for
taking so long to reach this conclusion
as, at previous venues, the urinals conformed to
the standard NCB pattern; a long wall tastefully decorated in black
bitumen paint, undercut by a narrow concrete drainage channel
(which always failed to deal adequately with a sustained flow), and
filled with oversized blue Polo Mints, fag ends and the occasional
crisp packet. The members of a team which had finished the
competition came in and, after an appraising look round, stepped
forward to the bowls while loudly analysing their performance in
the Oral Examination and the possibility of being awarded the
coveted individual prize. The ex-rescue man, who had listened to
their answers at the examination, looked along the row and
commented wryly, "Think a lot of these lads, because it's
the only chance of an individual ye'll get the
day!"
Many people who go for ski-ing holidays enjoy
their time on the snow covered slopes but equally enjoy the
"apres-ski" afterwards. So it was with the Inter-Station
Final. When the speeches and presentations were over, many teams,
supporters and observers repaired to a nearby hostelry to celebrate
the event in song and story, interspersed with suitable
refreshment. Custom and practice demanded that the winners'
cups were filled and replenished by contributions from teams not so
fortunate, then circulated around the assembled company. The
proceedings were usually directed by that inimitable Master of
Ceremonies, Station Officer Ian Malcolm and the singers accompanied
by Superintendent Harry Hamilton at the piano. I am sure that
anyone who has attended an after-final ceilidh will agree that,
after the final itself, it was the highlight of the rescue
season.
There was one incident, which may be cited as an
example of "black" humour, which had the potential to
upset the natural bonhomie of the ceilidh.
There was a suspicion that, because of an alleged irregularity in the screening arrangements, the winning team had gained an unfair advantage over the others and relationships between the team captains was rather strained. At the ceilidh, a team captain, who was noted for his excellent presentation of San Francisco, was asked to sing. After a short discussion with the accompanist, and, whether by accident or design, he launched into a spirited rendition of Your Cheatin' Heart! However, the situation was defused by the subtle diplomatic skills of the MC, delivered in his characteristic dulcet tones, and harmony prevailed.
The accelerated pit closures after the strike of
'84/85 sounded the death knell of the Scottish Inter-Station
Competition and the sole remaining pit, Castlebridge, was obliged
to participate in a new competition embracing the whole British
Coalfield comprising Scotland, England and Wales. Predictably, the
"Tartan" element maintained that the rest of the
coalfields had postponed the adoption of a truly national
competition until they had only one Scottish team to contend
with!
Having regard to the facts that I had
participated in the first Scottish Inter-Station Final, and my
abiding interest in rescue work, I was anxious to be present at the
first British Final. Correspondingly, I travelled to Doncaster with
two kindred spirits, Ex-Superintendent Frank Gibb and Ex-Station
Officer Ian Malcolm.
On the eve of the competition we decided to
visit the team at their hotel to offer our support and best wishes
and waited in the cocktail bar until they had finished dinner.
There we were, three grizzled veterans awaiting, we hoped, the
young champions of the ultimate rescue competition.
As the team filed into the bar we received a
typical warm and friendly greeting, "Good God, it's the
Last of the Summer Wine! Who lost the toss for Compo?"
Needless to say our hopes were fulfilled and Castlebridge became
the first team to win the prestigious British Inter-Station Final.
The Apres-final is another story.
Despite the initial misgivings about the Rescue
Competitions, I can say with confidence that they more than
fulfilled the primary objective of improving the technical
knowledge and operational efficiency of the teams.
In 1960, new appointees to the posts of Rescue
Station Officer and Superintendent were required to hold the Rescue
Officers Certificate and candidates for this new certificate had to
pass examinations administered by the Institution of Mining
Engineers. Cowdenbeath Rescue Station and Cowdenbeath Technical
College (later Lauder College, Halbeath) embarked on a joint
venture to prepare part-time brigadesmen for this
examination.
The examination was very exacting, comprising of
written papers in Mining Technology and Rescue Practice; success in
these papers allowed progress to the Oral and Practical
examinations in Legislation and Rescue Apparatus, and finally, to a
practical Gallery Examination.
Participation in the latter examination was a
daunting experience. Gone was the relative anonymity of the written
test conducted within the quiet cloistered surroundings of the
examination room. Instead, the candidate had to take charge of a
simulated rescue incident with attendant workmen, officials, team
captains and inspectorate, all part of the simulated exercise, but
there in the flesh to question, distract, and cajole the candidate
in his decision making. All this took place under the eagle eye of
examiners who seemed to take a Machiavellian delight in introducing
new problems just when the candidate thought that he had the
situation under control.
I have it on good authority that, at one Gallery
Examination, the candidate had been having a rough time but had
deployed all the teams successfully and was enjoying the slight
lull in the proceedings when, BANG! - a squib detonated
nearby. An examiner stepped forward and announced, "That was
an explosion at the top end of the face, please deal with this new
situation." The candidate was visibly shaken but, after
consulting the notes on his clipboard, said, "I'm going to
deploy an extra team"................... "And from where
are you going to get this extra team?" interrupted the
examiner, with a sardonic smile on his
face. Another quick glance at the clipboard,
then came the bitter answer,
"From the same bloody place as
you got your extra explosion," and, throwing down the
clipboard, the candidate stalked from the gallery.
I am pleased to record that the joint venture between Rescue Station and College produced examination results well above the national average and allowed many part-time brigadesmen to take up posts throughout Britain.
After a lapse of many years a course was started
at Lauder College in 1984 but was badly affected by the Miners'
strike.
By this time, the Rescue Service, perturbed about the high
failure rate in the examination for Rescue Station Officers, had
instituted a two-week "crammer" course immediately prior
to the examinations. Entry to this course was by special
examination and the remaining six brigadesmen on the Lauder course,
together with six others from various parts of Britain, qualified
to attend the course at a rescue station in the North of England. I
was keen to see how this course operated, with a view to
restructuring our own course, if need be, and was kindly given
permission to attend as an observer.
The course was intensive and
each day finished with a written examination of three questions.
The following day, the answers to the questions were critically
analysed by an Officer and advice given on content and layout. None
of the candidates from South of the Border had participated in a
joint course, being left to their own devices, with or without
support from sympathetic Officers.
This disparity in preparation
was commented upon when we all met for "informal
sessions" in the evening. This was also apparent at the formal
critique sessions each morning when the instructor's comments
on the Cowdenbeath lads' answers were mildly cosmetic while
some of the other answers attracted detailed criticism on length,
structure and content.
This state of affairs continued for a few
mornings without comment until, following a lengthy criticism, a
young lad from the Midlands piped up with,
"Ah doan't know
how us boooogers are supposed to compete wi' them Scotch lads
when thee've been on a course." Then, with a thumb in my
direction at the back of the room, "And they carry their own
bloooody Guru wi' 'em!"
I must confess that it was the
kindest four letter word I have ever heard associated with my
name.
Prior to the Inter-Station Final, the two
successful station teams participated in an extensive training
programme and, on occasions, I was asked to provide gallery tests
and/or give topical talks to the teams. From past experience I knew
that, towards the end of their punishing schedule, team members
were satiated with tests set by the Station Staff and facts and
figures provided by specialists from the NCB and Inspectorate.
Therefore, on one occasion, I decided to depart from the usual
procedure and introduce an element of light relief while still
having some relevance to the situation.
Many of the answers to
questions in the Oral Examination were, in essence, tests of
memory, recalling lists of equipment or statutory procedures, and
valuable points could be lost if a candidate "ran
dry".
With this in mind I chose for my subject -
Mnemonics - which is defined as "pertaining to memory
and methods of assisting recall".
I gave examples of mnemonics in everyday use,
including the musical scales EGBDF, which could be recalled
by the phrase, Every Good Boy Deserves
Football. Also the jingle for the number of days in the
month, Thirty days hath September, April June and
November..........etc.
Examples from technology were given,
including the elements in the formula for determining the power
developed by a reciprocating machine, and which could be recalled
by the word - PLANT;
Pressure
Length of stroke
Area of cylinder
Number of strokes
Time
Also the trigonometrical relationship between an
angle and the corresponding
sides of a right angled triangle,
namely;
Sine = Opposite
side/Hypotenuse SOH
Cosine = Adjacent
side/Hypotenuse CAH
Tangent = Opposite
side/Adjacent side TOA
and which could be represented by
the name of the well known Indian Chief,
Finally, from rescue practice, I gave examples
of mnemonics for memory busters such as - the equipment to be kept
at rescue stations and collieries, the factors to be considered in
the selection of sites for stoppings and the information to be
shown on mine plans.
As a practical exercise, I then asked the teams
to devise a mnemonic for the statutory duties of a captain, with
regard to the safety of his team, when working in an irrespirable
atmosphere.
Some of the returns showed promise but the one
which stood out for cynical topicality, brevity and clarity
was;
Fresh air base
You only supervise
Junctions to be fenced off
Inspections for safety
Apparatus checks
Area plan to be provided
Return at agreed time
Unless you have already guessed, the mnemonic
for the captain's duties towards his team may be translated
(prudently) into;
I like to think that the exercise had the
desired effect of relieving tension and was not prepared for the
verbal assault by an irate brigadesman after the
competition.
"You made me blow the individual
prize," he remonstrated.
"How?" I replied
apprehensively.
Ah got the question on the sites for
stoppings, and fae yer talk Ah kent it had sumthin' tae dae
wi' an Indian Chief, but the only wan Ah could think o' wis
GERONIMO and Ah only got twa items in before Ah ran oot
o' time!"
The best laid
schemes ................................?
No dissertation on rescue and firefighting would
be complete without reference to the firefighters' feathered
friend, the canary.
The use of birds in the detection of the
poisonous gas, carbon monoxide (whitedamp), which is a product of
fires and explosions, has extended over the
century. Even though much superior chemical and
electronic detectors are now available, legislation still requires
Central Rescue Stations to provide birds and a minimum of two must
be available at collieries; a classic case of "belt and
braces".
The supply of birds recalls the story of the two
rescuemen, from different pits, who had been summoned to supervise
the work of plugging the air leaks at six stoppings, which were in
widely scattered locations, adjacent to an underground fire area.
At least six birds were required to cover the locations but the pit
only carried the minimum of two required by law and a request had
been sent to the Rescue Station for more birds.
The rescuemen
waited impatiently on the surface and one, who was notorious for
endlessly extolling the virtues of "ma pit", remarked,
"If this had been ma pit we'd have been OK, fur we ayeways
keep at least twelve burds." The other long suffering
rescueman replied with a sigh, "Aye, and if this had been
Alcatraz, the Burdman could've trained the twa burds tae flee
between the stoappins!"
Because of its small blood bulk, a bird, when breathing in an atmosphere containing carbon monoxide, is affected approximately ten times more quickly than a man breathing in the same atmosphere. In this situation, rescuemen are trained to recognise the symptoms of distress in the canary's behaviour and this allows the man, AND THE CANARY, to be withdrawn before BOTH are adversely affected. The above statement is made to counteract the ill- informed comments of some media presenters which give the erroneous impression that the canary is deliberately sacrificed to save the workmen.
This mistaken impression was made painfully
clear to us on one of our many
visits to local primary schools, when a boy
refused to participate in any of the activities we had set up for
the class. On enquiry, the class teacher told us that the boy had
seen, on TV, the accounts of firefighting at Seafield Colliery and
had heard the damaging statements made by the presenter. Under no
circumstances would the boy have anything to do with "canary
killers".
It was only after showing the lad the special
bird cage which carries its own oxygen cylinder, and by dint of
gentle persuasion, that we were able to salvage some of our
reputation. He may not have understood the story which epitomises,
in bizarre fashion, the respect which is shown by miners to their
canaries.
Two men were detailed to clean up and repair the
badly damaged part of a roadway skirting an area which had been
sealed off due to fire. Although the risk of carbon monoxide was
remote, they were advised to take a canary "just in
case". When the deputy visited the place during the shift, he
saw the bird cage hanging from a girder alongside the workmen's
jackets, while the men were working in a low part of the roadway
some 20 metres inbye.
Conditions were bad where the men were working;
the roof was crushed, water covered the floor and the atmosphere
like that of a steaming tropical jungle. The deputy shouted at the
workmen that they should know better and that, to give effective
cover, the canary should be at the same place, breathing
the same air, as them.
One man, covered in grime and sweat, threw open
his arms and said, "Guid God Bob, look aroond ye, Ah widnae
bring ma Guid Mither in here faur less a puir wee
burd!"
There are certain circumstances in which the
reliability of the canary as a detector of carbon monoxide is open
to doubt, even when man and canary are breathing the same air. For
example, if the man is working hard while the canary is relatively
static on its perch, the increased breathing rate of the man makes
him susceptible to the effects of the gas before the canary shows
signs of distress.
This was borne out at an incident where men were
engaged in the heavy task
of clearing hot debris from the side of the
roadway in order to lay corrugated steel shuttering at the back of
the girders prior to cement injection. As a precaution, two birds
were sensibly positioned in the roadway and a man appointed to do
nothing else but watch for signs of distress in the canaries.
After
an hour of hard work some men complained of headaches and
dizziness
but, as the canaries had shown no signs of
distress, the deputy in charge put the symptoms down to the hot and
humid atmosphere of the workplace.
However, when two men collapsed,
he ordered an immediate retreat outbye to fresh air. The deputy
'phoned the controller for assistance, stretchers and blankets
and was asked in return if there was anything else he needed.
The
deputy glanced across at the men slowly recovering in the fresh
air, and the canaries chirping unconcernedly in their cages, and
replied ruefully,
"Aye, fund oot what they feed the canaries
oan and send some doon fer us!"
THE COLLEGE
In my early days as a student at Fife Mining
School, (renamed Cowdenbeath
Technical College), I was part of a composite
class of students, my group embarking on the new National
Certificate in Mining, the other more mature group studying for the
old "Six- Paper" Mine Manager's Examination.
These
groups combined for some subjects taught by the retiring Head of
Department who had been exposed for some years to the extrovert
charms of such notaries as Lawrence Daly (of NUM fame) and Dick
Abbot (son of No. 7 Pit Manager, John). Suffice to say that the
Head did not always see eye to eye with their radical
views.
On one occasion the Head was dealing with the
history of mining in Fife, stating that the Monasteries of Culross
and Dunfermline were given charters in the 13th century so that the
Monks and Abbots could work the coal.
Then, leaning over the bench,
with his half-round spectacles perched on the end of his nose and
his steely glare directed at Lawrence and Dick, he said;
"And
unfortunately some of them are still with us!"
Further Education Lecturers were required to be
flexible in the range of subjects they taught and changes in
timetables caused by absence or illness compounded this
requirement. However, a mining lecturer thought that the limit had
been reached when he was advised by the Head of Department that,
commencing the next day, he would be teaching business arithmetic
to a class of female sales assistants from the Co-operative
Society.
"Hold on," said the apprehensive lecturer,
"I know nothing about business arithmetic."
"It's easy," said the Head,
"just count in bags of sugar instead of bags of
coal!"
An ex-navy lecturer, whose main subject was marine electrical engineering, was asked by the Head to take classes of colliery electricians for colliery electrical engineering. The lecturer protested that he knew nothing about mining electricity but was assured by the Head that, "It's just the same as ordinary electricity but with a wee bit o' coal stoor thrown aboot it!"
Successful teaching depends on effective
communication between the lecturer and the student, but this may be
prejudiced when the lecturer, for various reasons, assumes that the
student has pre-knowledge of a subject.
A lecture on the effects of
roadway resistance to the flow of air appeared to be going well,
the lecturer demonstrating that the resistance of a length of
roadway containing a right-angled bend had ten times the resistance
of a similar length of straight airway. The object of the lesson
was to show that, for ventilation purposes, airways should be as
straight as possible.
However, the impact of the lesson was lost
when an intent, elderly student enquired; "Does it work the
same for left-angled bends?"
Conveying a precise meaning by the spoken word is relatively easy as the substance of the communication can be refined by verbal feedback from the student. However, in written examinations, the examiner has only one chance to make his meaning clear, while the response from the student may not be that which the examiner expected, as the following examples may indicate!
Question
Describe the steps to be
taken on discovering fire below ground.
Answer
Big ones.
Question
Describe the principle of
action of a three-throw pump.
Answer
It goes clack whoosh,
clack whoosh, clack whoosh. But if one of the valves is gummed up
it goes clack whoosh, clack whoosh, clack clunk.
Question
State what you know about
the mine gas BLACKDAMP.
Answer
Buggerall.
Question
State why stone dust is
spread in underground roadways.
Answer
Because the Government Inspector must be coming
down the next day.
Question
State the purpose of a
manometer below ground.
Answer
To count the number of men
passing a deputy's meeting station.
Question
State TWO advantages of a
flame safety lamp compared with a methanometer.
Answer
1. It's handy for nailing up screencloth.
2.
It keeps your jacket warm for piece time.
Question
Name the instrument used
to measure the humidity of the air below ground.
Answer
A
whirling barometer.
Question
Sketch the layout and
principal parts of a shearer loader.
Answer
I lost my shearer notes on the bus but
here's a drawing of a Mono pump.
A lecturer made up a mid-term examination paper
and put the paper into the office for typing. As he would be absent
for a few days, he arranged for a colleague to collect the papers
and invigilate the examination. On his return, the lecturer
collected the examination papers, the students' scripts, and
commenced to mark the scripts.
One of the questions was;
List
the items which must be included in a deputy's pre-shift
inspection.
The lecturer expected answers such as;
"state of roof and sides, presence of gas, supply of
supports", etc.
The lecturer was rather perturbed when some of
the answers included; "find a dry place, have a good supply of
paper or coal dust", and finally, the answer - "make sure
your trousers are down", confirmed that something was amiss.
On inspecting the typewritten examination paper he saw the
question;
List the items which must be included in a
deputy's pre-shit inspection.
A lecturer prided himself on his command of the
English language which sometimes obscured his duty to frame
questions in language which could be easily understood by the
student. Such a question appeared on an examination paper for
junior students.
Employing an annotated diagram, illustrate the
fundamental principles of a hydraulic
support.
The lecturer supervising the examination heard
the following whispered conversation.
First student;
"Whut dae
ye dae fur question 5?"
Second student, after a pause;
"Draw a bloody Dowty!"
Prior to the 1990s miners were classified
into three broad groups, mining engineers, electrical engineers,
and mechanical engineers, each having separate training, education
and statutory qualifications although duties carried a certain
amount of overlap.
Tentative steps were taken at intervals to
"rationalise" these three groups to provide a more
flexible workforce. In the 1960s a pilot scheme was introduced
with the object of providing an engineer who would be qualified
both electrically and mechanically and speculation centered on what
this hybrid engineer would be called.
A lecturer tagged the
following question at the end of an internal written
examination;
What should be the name given to a person who
is qualified to be a member of both the electrical
engineering and mechanical engineering staffs?
"Electromech" and "Mechelec"
were popular answers but the one which stood out was;
"A clever bastard".
Note.
In 1990 British Coal introduced a new scheme
whereby workmen and officials
of the future would be classified into two
categories, Mining with Electrical qualifications and Mining with
Mechanical qualifications.
After the 1939/45 war many of our students
hailed from Poland and other Eastern European countries so that
effective communication was doubly important.
Practical shotfiring classes were held and it
was a well-tried training aid that students be encouraged to
verbally describe their actions while physically carrying them out.
To this end, procedure sheets, which listed the sequence of
shotfiring operations, were made available to the students for
study and revision purposes.
A lecturer, while supervising an ex-Polish
student at a practical shotfiring exercise, listened to the student
as he opened an explosives canister prior to charging a
shothole.
"Open the canister bracket only one
canister to be open at a time bracket dot new line take out a
cartridge comma making sure it is a permitted explosive comma of
the correct type comma and is the largest cartridge of the charge
dot".
The lecturer realised that the student had taken
the advice about "speaking while doing" rather literally
and assured him that it was not neccessary to reiterate the
procedure sheets verbatim, far less memorise the punctuation.
The
student replied in good but halting English;
"You are far too
lenient sir. I practice the shotfiring with my wife at night; she
holds the procedure sheets, and it's no supper and no nooky
until I get them all right, dots and commas and
all!"
On occasions, the need for simple language could
work against the lecturer.
Lecturers who acted as examiners for the
Scottish Association for National Certificates and Diplomas
(SANCAD) will probably remember the Senior Secretary who
painstakingly scrutinised the final draft examination papers (which
had previously been subject to the alterations of a moderation
panel) to ensure correct English usage, that the questions were
unambiguous and that the exacting literary standards of SANCAD were
maintained.
The SANCAD Secretary wrote to a lecturer about a
question on strata control where the lecturer had described the
roof strata as "a thick bed of heavy sandstone". The
Secretary wrote to the lecturer and maintained that, as all
sandstone rocks had a common relative density of about 2.6, it was
misleading to describe one sandstone as heavier than another.
The
lecturer replied that the roof condition had been originally
described as "post", a local Fife term which conveyed the
strata condition very clearly, but in deference to other areas
which may not use the term, "heavy sandstone" was
substituted, heavy being synonymous with appearance and large grain
size. In the opinion of the lecturer this description gave an
accurate picture of the strata conditions to the junior students.
However, in the interests of technical accuracy, the Secretary was
at liberty to substitute the reference from a leading geological
text-book, "A massive bed of homogeneous
unlaminated
strata of varying grain size cemented mainly
with calcite or silica".
The lecturer received a one word
reply; Touche.
There are many stories about
"post".
When this thick bed of sandstone occurred
immediately above a coal seam it was able to support a wide
excavation without bending or breaking but, when the excavation
reached a critical width, the sandstone broke down with a
thunderous noise accompanied by extreme vibration. Strong steel
supports were bent and twisted and wooden supports broke like
matchsticks.
On these occasions, when the post took its first
break, discretion was the better part of valour and men literally
ran for their lives to a safer place back from the coal
face.
When the excavation was reaching this critical
width workmen were apprehensive, talking in whispers and all senses
attuned for a warning cry or other indication that the post was
about to break down.
Legend has it that a new paper-lad, distributing the late night Saturday papers, entered the local Miners Welfare Club and shouted, "POST", whereupon many of the old members dived under the tables!
Some Colleges were licensed by the Mining
Qualifications Board to conduct the Statutory Gas Testing and
Hearing Examinations which deputies and shotfirers are required to
pass at five yearly intervals. Strict rules were laid down for the
equipment to be provided and procedures to be followed for the gas
testing part of the examination but discretion could be used for
the type of hearing examination. The examiner merely had to be
satisfied that the candidate's hearing was such that he
"could carry out his duties effectively".
We were of the
opinion that, if the candidate carried out our instructions given
in a normal tone, then he would satisfy the criteria for the
hearing part of the examination. However, we were subject to the
whims of the current Government Inspector for the area (who could
be present at the examination) and some "suggestions"
were made to make the hearing examination more formal in
style.
One method was to suspend a pocket watch near to
the candidate's ear and ask him if he heard the
"ticking" as the watch was brought nearer to the ear.
On
one occasion the examiner was perturbed at the large number of
potential failures until he discovered that his watch had stopped!
Another Inspector suggested that the examiner should tap several
times with a pencil on the underside of the table, the candidate
would then tell the examiner how many taps he had heard.
The new hearing examination continued without
event until one occasion when, after tapping six times, the
examiner asked, "How many taps?"
The candidate answered,
"Four."
"Only four?" queried the Inspector in
an incredulous tone.
"It's aw richt neeb, ah heard them
a', it's jist that ah'm no very guid at the
coontin'," came the reply.
Discipline problems with mining students were
fortunately rare and usually confined to the younger student who
had just left school. Care had to be taken not to suppress the
boisterous enthusiasm of youth with harsh disciplinary codes, but
to divert this energy into productive educational channels until
the student was mature enough to apply his own self-disciplinary
code. For the first year or two it was indeed "education by
stealth".
Inevitably, one or two students took this apparently
mild discipline as a sign of weakness and exhibited traits of
laziness and disruption in class. A judicious 'phone call to
the Colliery Training Officer, to compare performance at work and
college and then to embark upon a joint remedial approach, solved
most of these problems.
Recently, as with many other organisations, this
effective and relatively simple approach to discipline problems
became ensnared in the paperchains of bureaucracy and we were
affected by model disciplinary codes of practice suggested by
Education Authority, Industry Training Board, Youth Training
Service and Students Charter. Verbal warnings from lecturers were
to be recorded and witnessed; a predetermined number of verbal
warnings resulting
in a formal written warning from the Head of
Department and this continued until, the ultimate sanction, a
letter was sent to the employer.
A head of department had invoked the ultimate
sanction, a letter was sent to the Manager of a local mine
cataloguing the nature, date and time of verbal and written
warnings given to a student and suggesting possible remedial
measures;
Option A - suspension for the rest of the term
with return conditional on guarantees of improved performance and
behaviour.
Option B - suspension for the rest of the session with
return the following session conditional on a joint review.
Shortly
after, the Head received a 'phone call from the Manager and was
asked to explain the new disciplinary procedures. The Manager
thanked the Head and his suggestions for Options A & B, but
that, taking into account the student's work record at the pit,
Option C was more appropriate.
"Option C?" queried
the Head.
"Aye," replied the Manager, "he's
secked!"
Option C then entered the
"jargonspeak" of the College to indicate the ultimate
deterrent.
THE PAN ENGINE
And now, in conclusion, a poem. There have been
many mining monologues
mainly about tragic occurrences such as
"The Blantyre Disaster"; but two stand out in my memory.
One, "The Brushers", tells at length, and in great
detail, of how the brushers transferred their working skills to the
football field, with explosive results! Unfortunately, although I
have heard it performed on several occasions (in the Lothians), I
have not been able to obtain a copy. However, I have been fortunate
in obtaining a copy of the other, courtesy of Mr John C Sampson,
formerly a lecturer in Mining Electrical Engineering at Fife Mining
School. It is a short ode which tells of an association with that
famous, or infamous, conveyor system, the "jigging pans"
and, in particular, the pan engine.
The jigging, or shaker conveyor was a line of
steel troughing, in 10 ft. sections (pans), connected to each other
by large diameter bolts and extending up to 150 yards in length.
The line of pans was connected at one end to a reciprocating crank
and gearing driven by a 10 to 20 hp compressed-air or electric
motor. The pans had semi-elliptical shaped tracks or cradles welded
to the underside, and, between this and a floor-mounted cradle,
rested a set of wheels or rockers. The drive arrangement of
reciprocating crank, rockers and cradles made the column of pans
lift a few inches and come to an abrupt halt on the quick forward
stroke, with a corresponding drop on the slow backstroke. This
stroke combination caused the coal in the trough to move forward a
short distance under its own inertia. The pan engine made 80
strokes per minute on the "quick jig" and, as can be
imagined, the vibratory forces involved made it necessary to hold
the engine firmly to the floor with heavy wooden "stells"
wedged to the roof and fitted with threaded height
adjusters.
The foregoing gives a short technical
description of this early type of conveying system but nothing
could prepare for the experience of working with this system in
adverse conditions such as;
When in low seams about 3 ft. high, imagine
working alongside a shuddering, reciprocating ribbon of steel where
the slightest contact inevitably meant serious injury;
When slack, bent or broken connecting bolts
superimposed a crescendo of hammering on the already overloaded
ear-drums and raised the spectre of mis-aligned pans knocking out
roof supports;
When the overloaded pan engine
"dances" over a hard floor, with the pan engineman
heroically trying to tighten the stells to a soft roof; or when the
shuddering pan engine attempts to bury itself in a soft floor while
the same poor pan engineman tries to keep the stells tight to a
hard roof.
Thank goodness the era of the jigging pans was
short and transitional between partial and full mechanisation, when
wiser councils prevailed to develop a stationary column of pans in
which the coal was transported by a moving chain running within the
pans.
What ails ye noo, ye lousy bitch,
Ye're near
as hot as bilin' pitch
Yer iron case ah scarce can tich,
Ye
burn ma haun's;
Yet MAVOR said, withoot a hitch
Ye'd jig
the pans.
Noo come awa, jig oot some coal,
Or else
we'll a' be on the dole,
Much mair o' this ah cannae
thole
Nor dinnae mean tae;
Ah wish ye in a hetter hole
Where
ah've ne'er been tae.
Ah ken ye're juist but fifteen hp,
This
thocht has often troubled me;
At a hunner yairds as level be
And
maybe steeper,
Ah've seen fifteen by twa' or three
Upon the
meter.
Ah ken that a' yer pans are clear,
Ah ken
ye're no too deep in gear
The sparkies tae have a' been
here
Tae test yer motor,
And aff the end bells cam fer fear
It wis
the rotor.
But what's the use o' a' this
girnin'
And what altho' yer motor's burnin',
The
heid yins say, wi' a' their learnin'
That you should
go;
So come noo, get yer gear wheels turnin'
And whit fer
no!
But yet ma sympathy ye've got,
If this can
ease yer troubled lot.
Fur costs have got ye by the throat,
And
left ye gaspin';
A drap o' ile ye've scarcely got,
E'en fur the askin'.
And thats no juist yer biggest hinder,
As long
as ye can dunt an' dinder
Short o' cradles, pins and bolts;
nae winder
Ye gi'e the ghost;
They'd rether roast ye tae a
cinder
Than raise the cost.
Ah think man's much the same way placed,
We
rise an' rush, then stop in haste;
Men an' machines,
e'en at their maist
Can only dare
Tae try an' gi'e
their very best,
Then gi'e nae mair.
(Thanks to J Sampson and apologies to R Burns)