The speaker at the fortnightly luncheon of the Dunfermline Business Club, in the
Royal Hotel on Thursday, was Mr D. C. Gemmell, mining agent, Wemyss Coal Company,
Ltd. His subject was "Half a Century of Coal Mining." Councillor Wm. Dick,
Transy, presided.
Mr Gemmell, after pointing out that coal mining was an industry with regard to which,
unfortunately, the man in the street was generally uninformed, proceeded to say -
One of the most common accusations made against us is that we have failed to make
progress through reluctance to adopt the improvements scientific research has placed at
our disposal. This is, in the main, incorrect. There are few industries in which progress
has been more revolutionary than in coal mining.
Perhaps the best way to appreciate these changes is to visualise a coal pit of fifty years
ago and contrast it with the colliery of today. It is well nigh fifty years since I started work
in the coal pits. I have seen this revolution take place, I might even claim to have had
some little share in bringing it about.
The pit I started work in was a typical Scottish
colliery of the period. It was working a fairly-thick seam comparatively near the surface.
the district was an old mining one, and it was not unusual for three generations to be working
together. The surface plant was simple. The output drawn was from 300 to 400 tons daily.
There was a rather impressive winding engine with an old-fashioned beam.
The winding ropes were flat hemp, and only one hutch was drawn at one time. The winding
engine, by an ingenious arrangement of shifting gears, did the pumping of water during the night
shift.
There were few men employed on the surface. The engineman worked a twelve hour shift
and had to fire the boilers on the night shift. The only other engine on the surface was one
driving the ventilating fan. The coal was tipped from the hutches over a bar screen direct into
the waggons. Only two varieties of product - round coal and dross - were sent to the market.
Our customers must have been easier to please in these days. I cannot recall hearing any serious
complaints.
FIRST COAL CLEANING PLANT.
I remember at a new pit in the district, where almost the first coal cleaning plant in Scotland
was erected, the young manager was excessively proud of his plant (we called them travelling
screens in these days) and invited his friends to see over it. Among these was a veteran
manager, then retired. The young man took him into the screens where the material was
slowly passing along the steel band. A large number of pickers were busy throwing aside
large pieces of stone. The manager explained to his old friend the great advantage of
the innovation, saying that previously these stones would have gone to the customer
and been the cause of trouble.
"Quite true," asserted the veteran, "but in my young days we kept that sort
of thing in the pit." There was more than a modicum of truth in the old man's criticism.
The provision of elaborate cleaning plants has tended towards a carelessness in the nature
of the product sent from the pits. The miner of today pays little heed to the filling of his
coal, and modern methods provide him with an excuse for his carelessness.
Underground
we had the same simple methods. The transport from the coal face to the pit bottom was
in the main done by manual labour. Where the roads were long, ponies were used, and
only in dipping roads was mechanical power applied.
Electricity was not then at our disposal, and in the pit I am describing, a steam engine
did the hauling up the dook. This engine was placed at the pit bottom. During the
night it dealt with the water from the dip workings.
All coal was worked by hand.
The "iron man" at that time was just being spoken of as a wonder of the future.
The miners worked usually three in a place - an older man, a young man in his teens, and a
boy. The coal was undercut by hand. This was a hard job, and necessarily done in a cramped
position. The young man did the transport work, and the boy filled the hutches and bored
the shot holes.
OPPORTUNITIES FOR LEARNING.
There were opportunities of learning for the younger men, and they in turn got places
for themselves, thus becoming fully fledged colliers.
The hours were long - usually from 6 o'clock in the morning till 4 o'clock in the
afternoon. There were no legal restrictions on the length of day. In Fife the miners were
more fortunate an eight-hour day having been secured by agreement long before this was
enacted by law.
The wages paid were about 4s per day for a man. Boys were allowed to start underground
at the age of 12 years. I started myself at the age of 12½ years; my wage was 1s per
day. I started work at the coal face without any previous instruction or experience. The
roof of the seam was supported by timber, which in these days was not the convenient
size or shape we know so well today. It was mostly home timber, cut from plantations on
an adjoining estate.
We did not have many accidents in that pit - it was considered a safe working. When
these did occur, however, our facilities for dealing with them were rather primitive. We
did have an ambulance box, but I can never remember seeing much in it. There was
one stretcher, and on this injured men were carried to their homes, sometimes long
distances. If the man chanced to be heavy, or the distance too great, we got the
loan of a horse and cart from an obliging farmer, who added to the man's comfort
by providing a bundle of straw.
In later years I had access to the cost sheets of some of the pits. The total cost of
production per ton of coal raised was between 3s and 4s. A satisfactory cost for a
colliery today would be fully three times this figure.
The management staff was small. A manager would often have two or three pits
under his charge. At each pit there was an oversman, with a few firemen. The miners
themselves had to do much of the repair and maintenance work that is now done
by special workmen.
NO MINERS' WELFARES.
I do not wish to convey the impression that in these days we were an oppressed
and miserable community. We had our pleasures too. The cost of living was low, and
perhaps we were easier to please in our amusements - at any rate, they cost us less
than they do today.
We had no Miners' Welfares, and had to make our recreations. We played
football for fun in these days, not for money. Even at our work there were gleams
of joy. At the junctions underground, where the younger lads congregated waiting
on hutches, many a prank was worked. A new lad starting was fair game for practical
joking. Many a weary journey, carrying a heavy burden, some of them made before
they realised they were being fooled.
A special occasion was the wedding of one of the men. He had to be "creeled",
and it took a full day off work for this important ceremony.
It would be easier to appreciate the great changes in the industry if one had seen it as it
was fifty years ago and had not again been in contact with it until today. The modern
mine must, of course, be larger. Greater depths have to be sunk to reach the coal.
Greater capital expenditure is involved, and higher outputs must be drawn to cover these
increased charges.
Legislation, too, has changed the character of mining. Not one of our industries has been
subjected to more legislative interference than coal mining. Whether this has been altogether
for its good is controversial, and this is neither the time nor the place for that.
COAL PIT ALMOST A FACTORY.
A coal pit today has become almost a factory. I mentioned earlier how few in number
were our finished products; today it is not uncommon for eight varying sizes of coal to
leave a pit. In addition to this, you can have almost an equal variation in qualities. This
development has been necessary to meet the demands of customers.
In the earlier days I have described to you, our aim, as miners, was to produce the
coal as large as possible. Small coal was unwanted and a drag on the market. Today,
the position is being reversed, and we have actually to break down large coal after it is
drawn to the surface.
The winding gear of the pit today is a much more elaborate machine than its predecessor.
Regulations demand the fitting of various gadgets to ensure safety while winding persons
and coal. This apparatus is of an ingenious nature, and gives security against forgetfulness
of the attendant.
It is interesting to compare the winding ropes of long ago with those in use today. I
spoke of a flat winding rope. The usual rope in use at a modern pit is of steel wire of the
best obtainable quality. The breaking strain of such a rope may be 200 tons; the hemp
rope, though four times the size, had a breaking strain of about 60 tons. It would be
impossible for me to describe to you, in the limited time at my disposal, the complicated
plant at our pits for coal cleaning and washing.
In the matter of coal washing, Scotland has taken a leading place, and we have in this
country - in this county, in fact - some of the largest washing plants in Great Britain.
At the modern colliery a common feature is the electric power plant. Electricity now plays
a large part in the production of coal, and it would be difficult to see how we could carry
on without this ally.
The policy of most colliery companies has been to generate their own power. The wisdom
of this is often questioned. Personally, I have never had any doubts, and have always
found it more profitable to do so.
CHANGES UNDERGROUND.
It is when we go underground that the magnitude of the change of method is fully
appreciated. At many of our pits today, hard working of coal has ceased, and all the
output is won by machinery.
I can recall the coming of the machine. It was met by fierce opposition at first by the
miners. I am not aware of any deliberate attempts at sabotage, such as happened in
other industries when labour-saving plant was introduced, yet the introduction of
machines was met by obstruction of a real nature.
Often this took the form of unreasonable demands in the matter of rates. It was difficult
for the miner to understand that he should handle, say, 10 tons of coal during the time
that he had previously handled 2 tons. It is probable that the management were at times
to blame in expecting too much, forgetting that what amounted to a revolution was in
process.
Scotland played a big part in the mechanisation of mining. One of the first successful
coal-cutters was designed and made in Scotland, and today two of the best known
machine makers have their works in this country.
In the matter of underground transport there have also been great changes. Hand-drawing,
which was general 50 years ago, is now reduced to a minimum. Horse haulage is fast
disappearing and this is particularly true of Fife, where comparatively few horses are now employed.
A good deal of sentimental nonsense has been talked about the employment of horses in mines.
Personally, I do not favour their use, and have been instrumental in changing to mechanical
haulage at several collieries.
During the whole of my experience I have only known of two cases of cruelty to ponies in pits.
After I have dispensed with ponies I have recognised these same animals in the possession of
hawkers, and have often thought if they could express their wishes they would have preferred pit work.
Some time ago I listened to an eloquent minister, who illustrated a point in his sermon by telling
how horses working for a period underground became blind. This is a fallacy. I had thought of
going to the vestry and correcting his error, but on second thoughts decided that truth was not
an essential quality in any story illustrating a good point in a sermon.
STEEL ROOF SUPPORTS.
During my working life great strides have been made in the support of roofs underground. It is
falls of roof that cause the greatest number of our accidents. This question continues to have the
serious attention of all mining men. In the change-over from timber to steel I have played a part,
and I am satisfied that the use of steel instead of timber has been one of the greatest improvements
in coal mining in my time.
Roadways in the modern mine have assumed more the nature of railway tunnels, and in some
mines today it is possible to travel for miles without bending. Not so many years ago, it was a
back-breaking proposition for a novice to travel a short distance underground.
A well-advertised and beneficial innovation in mining has been the introduction of protective
clothing. Even in such a small matter, the ingrained conservation of the miner has been displayed.
It has been a difficult feat to get him to wear a hat sufficiently robust to protect his head from unavoidable
knocks, and the suggestion that he should wear gloves was thought too ridiculous for serious
consideration.
HUMAN ASPECT OF CHANGES.
I have not endeavoured to describe the whole of the changes in equipment and method
which have taken place in the mining of coal. To do so would fill a book, and could not be
done in words free from technicalities.
The question which I believe will interest you most of all is "What has been the effect of
these changes from the human aspect?"
In this respect, no less than in others, a revolutionary change has taken place. The collier of
the last generation was a craftsman. His work was varied; he had to perform the whole of the
different operations that go toward the production of coal.
Today that is not so. The work has become specialised. This is the case in more industries
than mining, but in none has its effect been more marked.
A large proportion of the men could still be classed as skilled. Men who are engaged in the
operating of machines, or the securing of the newer roadways, require a considerable
amount of skill and experience, but the work of those handling the coal at the immediate
face calls for a less amount of skill.
The machine has undoubtedly eased the miner of the hardest and most uncomfortable
of his tasks, but it has left to him the most monotonous.
I cannot conceive of a job more dreary and uninteresting than to shovel coal continuously
into a receptacle that never fills.
I know that mining as a vocation has not been popular during the last few years. We are
suffering from a lack of recruits for all classes of mining - staff as well as workmen.
The reason for this may be in part economic. The industry has not been attractive from
either the point of view of capital or labour during the last twenty years. The greatest
task before mining engineers is to improve working conditions to a degree that will again
induce young men to take up a vocation which I believe to be one of the most interesting
jobs of work in the world.
Mr Gemmell was thanked for his interesting address on the motion of Mr R. H. Robertson.